22 December 2011

Eyeshadow Primers: Benefit Stay Don't Stray, Essence I Love Stage and Urban Decay Eyeshadow Primer Potion


Primers are a product I have only really started to experiment with in the past year. Eyeshadow primers in particular are a step I often skip as, unless you have really oily eyelids, which I don't, I don't consider them an essential. But recently I've picked up this trio of products so I thought I'd put them to the test and report back on how I got on.

To kick things off, I wore Essence I Love Stage on one eye, and Urban Decay Eyeshadow Primer Potion on the other. The Essence one is the latest primer on the block, and is cheap as chips at just €2.99. The Urban Decay primer is a much lauded cult classic -- I've got a mini version that came with the Naked Palette, but the full sized version is around €20.

I applied one to each eye at around 7am and applied my makeup as usual. Repeated checks throughout the day told me that both products were doing a good job at keeping my eyeshadow in place without creasing. By the time I removed my makeup that evening, there was no discernible difference to either eye.

I repeated this the next day but this time, headed out straight after work. This time, when I went to remove my makeup at around 11pm, I saw that my eyeshadow had creased on the Essence eye. This was after around 16 hours wear though, so I can't complain too much. However, the Urban Decay eye was still flawless. 




I tried the same experiment with Essence on one eye and Benefit Stay Don't Stray on the other. At €27, this is the most expensive product of the three. I was surprised then to see that, at around 8pm that evening, the Essence eye remained intact and creaseless, while the Benefit eye displayed slight creasing.

What all this taught me was that, with primers, as with so many beauty products, price is  no indicator of quality. In a normal day, the Essence product was just as effective as the market leading Urban Decay, and performed better on me than the Benefit product at around ten times the price. Where Urban Decay came into its own was in keeping my eyeshadow in place for a very, very long time. I will continue to use the Essence product day-to-day and use Urban Decay for when I know I'll be heading out straight from work.

None of the three impacted on the colour pay-off or vibrancy of my eyeshadow but this could be because I used them with matte, neutral shades. I will experiment with these products under brighter, bolder shades and let you know how I fare.

Do you use an eyeshadow primer and what products do you rate?

14 comments:

Dawniepants said...

Honestly I have never used one! I tend to sweep a little powder over the lids to dry them esp after liner but that's it. I think i have the creasing fear. It's why I cant stand cream eyeshadows!! The creases!

Karen said...

I tried the Essence primer and it creases so easily on me, such a shame because I've heard great things like this about it. I'm an Urban Decay Primer Potion and Two Faced Shadow Insurance fan!

fluff and fripperies said...

@Dawniepants, tbh I still don't think an eyeshadow primer is an essential so if what you're doing is working for you then why go adding another product into the mix?!

@Karen, sorry to hear the Essence one didn't work for you, which do you prefer between UD and Too Faced?

Leanne Woodfull said...

I swear by my Primer Potion, it's the best! Interesting to see how the Essence one worked just as well. I bought the ELF one recently to try out too, it'll be interesting to see what it's like!

Misseblog said...

I use the Urban Decay one, when I remember that is. I never really notice a difference. Especially with everyday neutrals xx

fluff and fripperies said...

@Leanne, look forward to hearing how you get on with the ELF product. I've still to try any of their stuff!

@Misseblog, I know what you mean - I have a bright green shadow I love but that creases something dreadful (and it wasn't cheap!) so look forward to seeing if the primers make a big difference under that...

cornflakegirl said...

I only really started using eyeshadow primers this year but it makes such a difference to the creasing even on my dry lids. My current favourites are UDPP and Stila's Primer Pot in Taffy.

Sarah Lanagan said...

The Laura Mercier eye primers are really great and make eye shadow much more intense and long wearing. The MAC prep ones aren't the best though...

Girlwiththeskew-earring said...

Oh Goody! I just bought the Essence one and I am loving it too. Glad I didn't shell out for an expensive one!

Kat (dollyrouge.ie) said...

This is a brilliant post Emma! Just goes to show that budget buys can often more than hold their own with the big guns! I have really oily lids, so primer is a must for me. Will definitely be popping the Essence one into my shopping basket soon :D

Independent Escorts in Mumbai said...

Your post is too beautiful and I really impressed by this blog. Everything is fairly defined in this post. You should continue do this type of post. It’s enjoyable post.

online dating expert said...

I love the it and will share it with my customers.

FROM online dating

Anonymous said...

look forward to hearing how you get on with the ELF product. http://beauty-wish-list.info

Nivedita said...

Where I live, the eyeshadow primers are so sifficult to come by unless you are looking at MAC :(